In May 2021, a family trust bought a waterfront property at 306 Spring Line Drive in The Moorings for $5.85 million. A few years later the owners tore down the existing house and built a new one, and in January 2026 that new house sold for $18.3 million, a record for the neighborhood. In October, a gut-renovated house on the same street, at 275 Spring Line Drive, sold for $19 million and took the record.
Two records on one street in ten months are interesting in their own right. They matter more as evidence. The two houses went to market in different ways, and the one that looked weaker on almost every listing measure brought the higher price. In The Moorings this year, the land under the house and the water in front of it set the top of the market. Whether the house was new or renovated mattered less.
The new build sold fast and close to its asking price
The house at 306 Spring Line Drive was built for its owners. Gulfshore Business reported that Stofft Cooney Architects designed it, Ficarra Design did the interiors and Rise Builders built it over 20 months. It has nearly 7,000 square feet, six bedrooms, nine bathrooms and 124 feet of south-facing water frontage. The house sits 11 feet above the flood level on 386 pilings and has hurricane-rated windows and doors.
It was listed at $19,495,000 and sold for $18.3 million 80 days after listing. Gulfshore Business puts the closing on Jan. 12, 2026. That works out to about 94 percent of the asking price. The sale also beat the previous Moorings record for a new house, $16.61 million, set in 2025.
The property went from a $5.85 million purchase to an $18.3 million sale, about three times the starting figure. The demolition, design and 20 months of construction cost the owners something, and that cost was never reported. Read the gap between the two figures as what a finished new house added on top of the land. It is not profit, and it does not tell you what the work cost.
The renovated house sold slower, further below asking, and still sold higher
The house at 275 Spring Line Drive was built in 2009. Lotus Construction gut-renovated it from top to bottom to a Stofft Cooney design, with interiors by Freestyle, and it sold furnished. It had sold for $12.5 million in 2022, according to county records cited by Naples Daily News.
Its time on the market looked nothing like the new build's. The same report says the house had been on and off the market since February 2025 with different agents. It was first listed at $23.5 million, cut to $20.5 million, withdrawn over the summer, and then sold for $19 million in an off-market deal. The final price was about 81 percent of the first asking price, reached after about 20 months of trying.
Listing data tends to make that kind of history look bad. Even so, the house sold for $700,000 more than the new build that had set the record ten months earlier.
What the extra $700,000 paid for
Divide each price by the size of the house and the order flips. The new build sold for roughly $2,600 a square foot of living space. The renovated house, with 8,019 square feet, sold for about $2,370. Per square foot of house, the buyer of the renovation paid less.
The larger lot accounts for the higher total. The house at 275 Spring Line Drive sits on a 0.86-acre gated corner lot on Moorings Bay. It is a double lot with two private docks, a Jet Ski platform and a separate carriage house with three garage bays. The seller's agent explained the price with the size comparison. He told Naples Daily News that the January record "was on a smaller parcel, and it was a smaller house." The buyer's agent called the property "impossible to replicate" because of its "nearly an acre of land on the water in the Moorings."
Prices for waterfront land just south of The Moorings help explain why. On May 1, 2026, a vacant waterfront lot of 0.55 acres at 980 Galleon Drive in Port Royal sold for $11 million with no house on it, Naples Daily News reported. Port Royal is a different neighborhood with its own prices, so that number is not a Moorings comparable. It does show the scale of what Naples buyers paid this year for waterfront land alone. Against that, a renovated house of more than 8,000 square feet on 0.86 acres of bayfront at $19 million is mostly a price for land and frontage, with a finished house on top.
Each sale shows what the land under it allowed. The family at 306 Spring Line Drive started with a lot that could hold a new house of nearly 7,000 square feet, and the new house sold quickly. The owners of 275 Spring Line Drive started with a 2009 house on a double lot, and the renovation kept a house sized for that lot. Waiting for a price that matched the land took time, and the land supported the price in the end.
Where an ordinary Moorings listing sits
Few buyers comparing The Moorings with Park Shore or Old Naples are shopping at $19 million. The same lesson about land still applies at lower prices, and the broader numbers show how patient this part of town can be.
In the Naples Area Board of Realtors September 2026 report, the 34103 ZIP code had a median closed price of $1,012,500, 273 active listings and an average of 121 days on market. Those figures include condos and single-family homes, and The Moorings spans both 34102 and 34103, so they describe the area around the neighborhood more than the neighborhood alone. In September, NABOR's Naples Beach area of 34102, 34103 and 34108 had a $1,292,500 median, 931 active listings and 132 average days on market. All of Naples had a $575,000 median and 99 days.
Listings near the beach took longer to sell than the Naples average in September 2026, and sellers there were waiting more than a month longer. The 80-day sale at 306 Spring Line Drive closed in January, so its timeline does not match the September window. The comparison is still useful. A new house with wide south-facing frontage sold faster than the typical listing in its ZIP code, while the renovated house sold on a timeline much longer than average. NABOR's October figures are scheduled for release on Nov. 20.
Reading a Moorings listing with the land first
Both records point to the same order of questions for a buyer weighing a Moorings home this season. Start with the lot. Ask for its size, whether it is a single or double parcel, how many feet of water frontage it has and which way the frontage faces. 306 Spring Line Drive's 124 feet of southern frontage was part of the listing's headline. So were 275 Spring Line Drive's northwestern bay views across a double lot.
The house comes second, and three things about it carry the most weight: when it was built, how far it has been renovated and how it was built. A 2009 house that has been gut-renovated and a new house on pilings can both be described as feeling new. They still sold at different prices per square foot and on very different timelines this year.
Then read the price history. A first asking price of $23.5 million and a final sale at $19 million could look like a failed listing. In The Moorings in 2026, that same history ended in the highest price the neighborhood has recorded. Our earlier look at selling a home in The Moorings and our note on the season's changes along the neighborhood's edge cover the area around these streets.
FAQ
What is the record sale price in The Moorings? $19 million, for the renovated house at 275 Spring Line Drive, reported by Naples Daily News on Nov. 6, 2026. It replaced the $18.3 million record set in January by the new build at 306 Spring Line Drive.
Did the renovated house sell for more per square foot than the new one? No. At about $2,370 per square foot, it sold for less per square foot of living space than the new build, at roughly $2,600. Its higher total price came from a larger house on a 0.86-acre double lot.
How quickly do homes near the beach in Naples sell right now? In September 2026, listings in NABOR's Naples Beach area averaged 132 days on market, compared with 99 days for Naples as a whole.
If you are comparing a new build with a renovated home in The Moorings, or deciding how to price a lot you already own there, Team Faby can go through the lot size, frontage and recent sales with you before you set a price or make an offer. Schedule a consultation today.